Showing posts with label tabloid bullshite. Show all posts
Showing posts with label tabloid bullshite. Show all posts

Sunday, 5 December 2010

PCC says it's OK to lie

So after a couple of months of pondering, the PCC have got around to replying to my complaint. You remember the one, where I pointed out that Richard Littlejohn was talking out of his arse when he claimed that "any Afghan climbing off the back of a lorry in Dover goes automatically to the top of the housing list"?

He said this despite the fact that it is simply not true - asylum seekers do not even join the housing queue and illegal immigrants (for fairly obvious reasons) aren't entitled to council houses and benefits at all. So Richard Littlejohn, who likes to portray himself as a man who speaks uncomfortable truths, made something up. He gave false information to his readers. He lied. And he did all this in an article that essentially blamed Afghan asylum seekers for the fact that an ex-soldier who served in Afghanistan couldn't get a council house, thus continuing the Mail's policy of whipping up anti-Muslim and anti-immigrant hatred based on misinformation.

The PCC code is very clear on such matters. Section one, clause one says:
i) The Press must take care not to publish inaccurate, misleading or distorted information, including pictures
And they've gone further on the subject of asylum seekers, issuing a note to editors that says:
"The Commission – in previous adjudications under Clause 1 (Accuracy) of the Code – has underlined the danger that inaccurate, misleading or distorted reporting may generate an atmosphere of fear and hostility that is not borne out by the facts."
So obviously after I pointed out that Littlejohn had published inaccurate, misleading or distorted information that generated an atmosphere of fear and hostility that is not borne out by the facts, there was only ever going to be one outcome:

Commission’s decision in the case of Stable v Daily Mail

 

The complainant considered that the article falsely stated that “Afghans climbing off the back of a lorry in Dover” were given precedence in the allocation of council housing.

 

The Commission acknowledged the complainant’s concern over the statement; however, it had to consider the remark in the context of the article in which it appeared. The article had been clearly presented as a comment piece, in which the columnist expressed his concern that a soldier who had served in Afghanistan had not been granted a council house. The Commission considered that the columnist had exaggerated and simplified the example of housing immigrants for the purpose of stressing his assertion that the “system of government exists simply to punish those who do the right thing”. It emphasised that the newspaper should take care when using such rhetorical methods of expression that readers would not be misled into understanding that they reflected statements of fact. In this instance, on balance it considered that readers would be aware that the columnist was not accurately reflecting the government’s policy on the housing of immigrants, but that he was making an amplified statement for rhetorical effect. It was therefore the Commission’s view that, on this occasion, readers generally would not be misled in such a way as to warrant correction under the terms of Clause 1 (Accuracy) of the Code of Practice.

The covering letter notes that I can't complain about the decision or ask them to reconsider, but notes that they'll forward my letter to the editor. You couldn't make it up.


Now that the PCC has been quite clear that it's OK for journalists to lie for rhetorical effect, I think I'm on safe ground when I say that Richard Littlejohn is a fine, upstanding journalist, the Daily Mail is a wonderful publication whose employees can be proud to work for it, and that the Press Complaints Commission is an effective, relevant and entirely useful organisation that continues to make an excellent case for ongoing self-regulation of the UK media.


Wednesday, 13 October 2010

Mail has egg on its face over statistics (again)

The Daily Mail, always first with the news that matters, today proudly reports that a man in Cornwall has found an egg that isn't egg-shaped. Or, as the headline puts it:

"What a shellshocker! Chef's perfectly round egg is a BILLION-to-one discovery"

There's a little-known byelaw affecting the Kensington area that requires all sub-editors to use an egg-based pun in the headline when working on stories about eggs, so we'll let that abomination pass. Instead, let's focus on the eye-catching claim that the round egg is "one in a billion".

The second paragraph of the story repeats the egg-straordinary (sorry) statistic:

"James Church was working the early shift in Newquay, Cornwall, when he made his billion-to-one discovery."
Where does this come from? Has there ever been a detailed study of egg-shapes? Have they found an esteemed egg-spert (sorry, again) in chicken-related matters who knows all about the probabilities involved in egg-shape distribution? Has the Mail even managed to come up with a single fact to egg-splain (last one, promise) why this is a one-in-billion occurrence?

What do you think?

What we do get is a quote from the chef:

"I've probably cracked at least 100,000 eggs in my time as a chef but I've never seen one like this."
Right. So of the 100,000 eggs he's cracked, one has been perfectly round. I'm no expert, but I'm pretty sure that counts as anecdotal evidence that the chance of finding a round egg is one in 100,000. Not one in a billion. And even that is a totally unscientific, untested and unreliable "fact".

It seems the Mail has finally decided to give up twisting the facts in favour of just making them up.

And even if this claim were true, is it really so remarkable as to be considered news by a national newspaper? According to the British Egg Information Service (no, really), the UK gets through almost 11 billion eggs each year. If perfectly round eggs are one in a billion, we should be seeing 11 of them each year in this country alone. That's roughly one every five weeks. Based on the chef's experience that one in every 100,000 is round, Brits should be stumbling across 110,000 such eggs each year - more than 300 per day.

With a war raging in Afghanistan, toxic sludge seeping across central Europe, and one of the most dramatic rescues of all time taking place in South America, does the Daily Mail REALLY have nothing better to write about?

Monday, 13 September 2010

Who's furious, exactly?

You know what you're getting with the Daily Star and progressive liberalism it ain't, so complaining about the horrendous way it reported a "story" about transsexual prisoners being allowed to request a strip search by a member of staff who shares their adopted gender seems rather redundant. Let's just say that the paper ran with the headline*:

BEHIND BRAS
Tranny strip-search fury

...and that it all went downhill from there, even managing refer to people whose:

"meat and two veg are still intact"
Classy. As I said, complaining about the use of language such as "trannies" in a Daily Star story is somewhat pointless. Suffice to say it wouldn't pass muster with the good people at Trans Media Watch. So let's ignore the bigotry (and the, er, interesting choice of photo on the website) and focus on the facts, starting with that headline. There's "fury" about these new rules, apparently. As the first sentence says:

"Female prison officers are angry at new rules which mean they may ordered to strip search transexual [sic] lags"
Further down we're told that;

"The move is creating unrest among female prison officers reluctant to strip-search male inmates."
But the only quote in the story, direct or otherwise, comes from a spokesman for the Ministry of Justice who, somewhat predictably, points out that these are not "new rules" but draft guidelines that have yet to be approved or implemented. Nowhere is there any evidence whatsoever of "angry" prison officers reacting with "fury". There's no quote from a named or anonymous prison officer expressing any opinion at all. There's not even that tabloid staple, the made-up quote that perfectly matches the paper's editorial line using language only ever deployed by tabloid hacks. They can't even get a response out of the Prison Officers Association, who are never shy about generating a media profile.

In short, there's absolutely no evidence of anyone being "furious" or "angry" about the proposed guidelines. Yet the Star manages to put "fury" in the sub-head, "angry" in the opening sentence and "unrest" further down the story.

Surely if prison officers up and down the land are up in arms, as the paper suggests, they'd be able to find at least ONE person who could actually say so?

*That's in the paper itself - the website used the slightly tamer "Female guards may be forced to search male trannies"

Wednesday, 1 September 2010

Indisputable evidence of gayness

Today's Telegraph covers the Guido-powered rumour that William Hague is secretly gay and is having an affair with his special adviser. What evidence does journalist Martin Beckford - he of "Pope has Catholic views" fame - have to back up this allegation?

"Rumours about their closeness had been swirling around Westminster and the internet after photographs were published showing Mr Hague and Mr Myers walking and laughing together, dressed casually and wearing sunglasses."
Well. That proves it then.

UPDATE: The spad in question has now quit, citing the unbearable pressure the groundless speculation was having on his family. Hague himself has released an absolutely heartbreaking statement in which he reveals that he and his wife would dearly love to start a family but keep suffering miscarriages. I do hope the scumbags who suggested his lack of kids was evidence of a sham marriage feel proud of themselves. Tomorrow's papers will go to town on this and every single one, including the Telegraph, will point the finger of blame at "bloggers". I'm willing to bet that the Telegraph will not hold its hands up and admit contributing to the shitstorm in today's paper.

Thursday, 26 August 2010

Tabloids not spooked by lack of facts, proof, evidence etc

The middle of August is always a slow time for the media, which goes some way to explaining why a woman putting a cat in a bin led bulletins on 24-hour news channels for much of the week (I'd have been more impressed if she'd put a bin in a cat, but there you go).

So editors up and down the land practically came in their pants with excitement when"real-life James Bond" Gareth Williams was found dead in his Pimlico flat earlier this week. Spies! Intrigue! Gayness! It's a story that has pretty much everything, which is why the press covered it all with such sensitivity.

Did Al-Qaeda bump off suitcase spook?
Asked the Sun website yesterday. Probably not, said the front page of, err... today's Sun:

Murdered spook was a cross-dresser
"MURDERED MI6 worker Gareth Williams was a secret transvestite who may have been killed by a gay lover, detectives said yesterday."
Ah, those pesky transvestite Al-Qaeda agents! A well-known issue among the Islamist extremist terrorist community. Incidentally, the "evidence" that proves the deceased was a transvestite is the claim that "women's clothes that would fit a man" were found in his flat. Well that settles it, then. By the time we get on to page seven the paper has decided to hedge its bets and created one of the most tabloid friendly headline-and-intro packages of recent months (which, unfortunately, is not online):

MI6 Gareth... Murdered by a gay slayer or a foreign spy
"Police believe transvestite MI6 intelligence expert Gareth Williams was killed by a gay lover - or a foreign spy."

Or, as the Mirror claims, one of his colleagues. Or maybe one of his friends:

"Detectives are investigating whether colleagues of codebreaker Gareth Williams, 31, are linked to the puzzling death ... Dismissing suggestions of an assassination by foreign agents as fantasy, security sources said it was possible he may have been attacked by a friend."
Or maybe a fucking Moomin, for all they know. The Star preferred to take a more mature, grown-up attitude to the case:

MI6 spy stabbed to death and stuffed in sports bag to rot
Classy. I'm sure his family were delighted to see that on the newsstands this morning. Plus, as the Mail points out:

"Toxicology tests have been ordered to see if Mr Williams had been poisoned. Lurid speculation that he had been stabbed or even dismembered was discounted by police sources."
It's little wonder the Mail has such disdain for "speculation", as all their coverage is totally rooted in confirmed facts:

Did spy's killer steal secrets?
Er, probably not. As the Mail's sister paper Metro points out:

"Nothing had been stolen".
However, the Mail has some lurid speculation to be getting on with:

"Police fear that his murderer could have taken classified material - possibly held on a laptop or MP3 player - which could be sold on to Britain's enemies."
And that's not the only thing the Mail is fearful of:

"One fear is that an area used by MI6 to house operatives ... had now been compromised."
Ye gads! Which treacherous organisation could be responsible for compromising national security in this way?

"The maze of streets around London's Victoria and Pimlico districts ... provide the ideal cover for safe houses used by MI5 and MI6. Dozens are owned by the Security and Intelligence agencies."
That little security titbit comes from, you've guessed it, the Daily Mail. The paper really goes to town on the issue, including helpfully telephoning the mother of one of Mr Williams's colleagues to ask if her son had been involved in a gay relationship with the victim - no room for lurid speculation here. It has also commissioned a piece on "the intriguing truth about life as 21st century spook". It notes that said life is "surprisingly mundane", with workers "spending their days in an office trawling through emails".

So, in summary, Gareth Williams was a real-life James Bond whose life and work was pretty mundane. He was stabbed, poisoned and strangled to death by a gay-slaying Al-Qaeda agent who was a colleague and a friend and police fear that secrets that were not stolen from his flat could be sold to Britain's enemies.

It's a classic example of the media having no idea what's going on, but having pages to fill nonetheless. In any high-profile murder case getting to the facts can be tricky for journalists, but when the victim works for Britain's most secretive employer they come up against a brick wall. At which point all they can do is guess, speculate, talk to sources who aren't actually connected to the case and copy what other journalists are saying, because if something's been said on Sky News, well, it must be true. Being accurate is no longer important. All that matters is being first with something, anything, so that a year from now when the case comes to court the paper can run a little picture of today's front page alongside a boast about how they "were first" with the news.

The result is a mess like this story. When you cross-check the stories against each other they quickly become ludicrous, but how many of each paper's readers will also look at the coverage in other outlets?

Quite aside from the factual inaccuracies, how traumatic must this be for Mr Williams' friends and family? It's bad enough that they've lost a loved one, now they have to put up with "lurid speculation" about his private life, ill-informed gossip spread across the newsstands, and disturbing headlines like that employed by the Star.

All hacks and hackettes on journalism law courses are told that you can't libel the dead. However, that doesn't mean you should go out of your way to piss all over their memory in order to stand up a sensationalist headline.